Month: October 2018

Review: Historia económica de España

cover historia economica de españa

Buy Historia económica de España

Or use this affiliate link: https://amzn.to/2NC9Lq0

To find more books on the history of Spain, check out the List history of Spain books section.

Disclosure: I may earn a small commission for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this website. Your purchase helps support my work in bringing you the podcast and a long list of books about Spanish history.

Review Historia económica de España

Historia económica de España, written by a team of 19 economic historians led by Agustín González Enciso and Juan Manuel Matés, is a monumental work (+1000 pages!) in Spanish about the economic history of Spain. The book offers both a general perspective of the long-term evolution and factors that have influences Spanish economics, as well as a detailed account about the economics of each period. The text is complemented by abundant graphics, images, and academic references to ensure the understanding and truthfulness of the information offered.

Unfortunately, there are no reviews on Amazon or elsewhere about this book, but it’s used as the guideline and reference book in many History Departments of Spanish Universities, I think that guarantees enough the quality of this work, apart from the fact that 19 historians have collaborated in this work to give birth to this masterpiece.

Review: Fernando VII: Un rey deseado y detestado

cover fernando vii un rey deseado y detestado

Buy Fernando VII: Un rey deseado y detestado

Or use this affiliate link: https://amzn.to/2NYS7Ml or https://amzn.to/2S53LVb if you prefer Amazon.com

To find more books on the history of Spain, check out the List history of Spain books section.

Disclosure: I may earn a small commission for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this website. Your purchase helps support my work in bringing you the podcast and a long list of books about Spanish history.

Review Fernando VII: Un rey deseado y detestado

Fernando VII: Un rey deseado y detestado, written by historian Emilio La Parra, is the best Spanish-written biography of one of the most influential kings of the history of Spain (and for bad), Ferdinand VII of Bourbon. He has been labelled by many as the worst king in Spanish history, which is really something considering the quantity of incompetent kings Spain has had. The book has 760 pages, so it’s pretty dense, and of course you need to know Spanish to read it. This book of Emilio La Parra won the Comillas Awards in the category of History, Biographies and Memoirs that Tusquets Editorial concedes annually, which demonstrates its quality. Sorry folks, I couldn’t find a single biography in English about this man!

This is what the buyers say on Amazon:

The book is magnificent. Nice reading even for non-experts like me. I have managed to understand for the first time why this Bourbon king, so morally unpresentable, could have been so desired. Rigorously and carefully documented. Absolutely recommended.” – Tomás Martín Camaño

If Juan Carlos I leads the third restoration of the Bourbons in Spain at the hands of Franco’s dictatorship (the Monarchy of the Movement, which becomes a parliamentary monarchy through the so-called Transition: a process controlled by Franco’s power), the first restoration of the Bourbon dynasty is played by Fernando VII. Its importance in the recent history of Spain is enormous. This Spanish monarch was a man very concerned about his image, very easily influenced and distrustful, extremely hypocritical; Hedonist and glutton, stood out in the billard and card games. Obsessed with money and possessions, the monarchy considers its patrimony and governs it with the meticulousness of a manager. Essentially, it is the motor of the counter-revolutionary movement to which the liberals (divided between moderate and exalted) are opposed with great ingenuity. It establishes a personalist, tyrannical monarchy. Perpetrates several coups d’état and when it fails, he entrusts the Hundred Thousand Children of San Luis, the executing arm of the monarchical alliance, to complete the task. Intransigent, repressive, criminal. He was a popular, easy-going king. Professor Emilio La Parra’s book is well written and will not disappoint lovers of history and biography.” – JMSam

“Very interesting. Easy to read if you like history. Essential to understand the historical figure of Ferdinand VII.” – Ángel Aznar Canales

Summary of reviews: all are very positive reviews, I couldn’t find any negative review on Amazon or elsewhere. Give it a chance if you know Spanish, totally worth your money!

Review: A Concise History of Spain

cover a concise history of spain

Buy A Concise History of Spain

Or use this affiliate link: https://amzn.to/2xqA7jG

To find more books on the history of Spain, check out the List history of Spain books section.

Disclosure: I may earn a small commission for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this website. Your purchase helps support my work in bringing you the podcast and a long list of books about Spanish history.

Review A Concise History of Spain

A Concise History of Spain, written by historians William D. Phillips Jr. and Carla Rahn Phillips, is the best English introductory book about the history of Spain, that covers from Prehistory to the contemporary history of this Southern European country. And all in around 450 pages, so I consider A Concise History of Spain THE book that best introduces and summarizes the history of Spain and it’s suitable for all audiences.

This is what buyers of this book say on Amazon:

“An excellent piece of work.” – Gary L. Hyde

As a concise history it is clear and effective.” – Robert Riter

And this is what members of the Goodreads community say:

A Concise History of Spain is a fast-paced overview of Spanish history, a subject on which I am not well-versed.. Spain’s diminished presence on the global stage over the last century can lead one to forget the country’s importance in history. There are sections of the book that lack depth, but it is, after all, a concise history. It is well-written and filled with information. Spain has a fascinating history, and this book provides a helpful introduction to it.” – Seth Woodley

It is what it says, a “Concise History” of Spain, so this works well as an informational resource, and I enjoyed the first 2/3 of the book. Up until the 20th century it’s definitely a good overview without going into extreme detail, and it gives fairly good background on what leads up to the events of the 20th century.

Unfortunately, when the book gets to the Spanish Civil War, it goes completely off the rails and contains serious errors and omissions. The omissions might be understood given that it’s a concise history (the Maquis aren’t even mentioned by name, only that some armed conflict against Franco’s regime continued up until the 50’s), but the errors are bizarre. The authors incorrectly state that Franco’s Nationalists only targeted “those on the other side of the conflict” which is ludicrous, given that even the most cursory examination of the war shows that they deliberately and repeatedly bombed civilian centers, and regularly tortured and executed political prisoners. Most egregiously, the authors state that the Republican government’s purging of the POUM in 1937 was due to the POUM and anarchist fomenting a “rebellion” (!) against the government, when the reality is that the communist-controlled government attempted to disarm the anarchist and Trotskyist militias, resulting in the street battles that followed. The authors repeat the decades-old and long-since disproven reversal of chronology on this for some reason, and even state that George Orwell, who was a first-hand witness to it, didn’t understand the situation!

Probably most head-scratching is the soft, even positive treatment given the Franco regime in the post-civil-war years by the authors. There’s scant mention of the Republican, anarchist, socialist, and communist prisoners who were executed, and no mention of the horrific crimes committed by Franco’s government by way of torture and rape, not just of enemy combatants but their family members as well. Negligible discussion is given to the slave labour employed by the fascist Nationalist government, or that they had concentration camps, and mass graves. The authors even start interjecting their own unnecessary opinions at points, for no valid reason.

In the end what really makes this book problematic is the complete lack of citations. This would be forgiveable in a high school essay, but this is a published book on history and when the authors make contentious claims they need to back them up. Instead, they resort to clichés such as “others would say that,” or “some scholars argue that,” without giving any sources for these supposed contrary opinions.

Get this from the library if you must, read the first portion, but get rid of it and read some real histories of Spain once you get to the 20th century.” – Brian Clement

Summary of reviews: Most reviews are positive, highlighting the fact that it’s a concise and introductory book that achieves its aim. There are some negative reviews due to the summary tha the authors make about the complex and controversial 20th century Spain, with the Spanish Civil War and Franco’s regime, but there is a broad agreement in giving a positive review about the rest of the book.